“It’s not about the quality of the sketching, but the variety and exploration of the idea that matters.”
Leah Buley, quoted by Jared Spool in a new article on exploring design options and making decisions about them. Good article and very applicable to my current project, where we are starting to develop a set of layout alternatives and visual design options for an online catalog. Especially liked the point about purposely looking at extremes to help sharpen your thinking.
“Too many CIOs get lost in the thicket of what platforms are hot today, what buzzwords are ascendant, what tool got the reviews here, or there, and never take time to sit down with a user and observe, and listen, and talk.”
From Mark Hurst on Good Experience. Helpful quote as I prepare to host a training session on conducting customer interviews next week. Good dialog illustrating why it’s important for management to buy in to user-centered principles.
“CSS is the weakest link in the web developers toolbox. The problem goes deeper than CSS’s lack of variables. Unlike the “function” in programming, CSS has no fundamental building block.”
Chris Eppstein, the author of Compass writes up a solid argument for the need of abstraction in stylesheets. I’ve been toying around with Compass and the Sass language over the past few weeks and things look very promising.
Beyond the initial PC vs. Mac appearance of this article, it really points to how a great design team has worked to unify a company and present a unified message. No matter the size of your company, I think every design team struggles with focusing the company in one direction, especially when there are many people contributing to product development and content.
Great interview from Mark Hurst with Brian King on the re-design of Courtyard by Marriott. A great case study on segmentation, observation, user-centered design, branding, and prototyping. Fun to see these familiar concepts applied in a domain that’s less familiar (to me anyway). I loved the description of business travelers being invited to a life-size prototype of the new lobby, built out of foam core to see how they would react to Marriott’s innovations.
“There’s a common misconception that visual design’s role is only to
provide a pleasing veneer on the page. In fact, visual design’s big
role is to boost overall communication.”
From Jared Spool’s recent article on the interplay between good visual design, IA, and content design. He also argues that to really succeed, it is better to have people who are strong in all three areas, not just specialists who are good at just one of them. I think I agree.
Jakob Nielsen recently ran a Twitter post through 5 rounds of iterative design to get the impact he wanted. At first blush I was thinking, “That sounds like a lot of effort to optimize a Tweet!” But if you are using twitter as a marketing medium, I guess it makes sense. (Far as I can tell, these were just design rounds; he wasn’t running a user study or anything.)
See his article for lessons learned in each round, from concision to focus, impact, and re-tweetability. (There, I’m making up new words right and left.)
He finishes the article with a notable quote: “Text is a UI. It’s a common mistake to think that only full-fledged graphical user interfaces count as interaction design and deserve usability attention. ... In fact, the shorter it is, the more important it is to design text for usability.”
I’m an amateur singer-songwriter when I’m not at work or asleep (let’s say for now that they’re mutually exclusive), and for the last few years I’ve been writing and performing material with different bands, duos, and on my own. Throughout that time I’ve tried different things to get my songs from pen and paper to studio and stage. It’s a typical creative process – start with an idea, work, work, work, end with a performance or a recording or both. For the longest time, my process for getting from point A (“Mmmm…good idea…”) to point B (“We’re going to play a song for you called…”) was pretty straightforward.
It looked like this:
The whole thing felt a bit tedious from time to time, but overall, it was working for me, you know. I was successfully getting to the record and perform part of things often enough that it was enjoyable.
So a few weeks ago I had this tremendous breakthrough. I had an idea for a song, and it occurred to me that maybe I should just skip all the other steps and just record it. I know, I know, it sounds crazy.
So I started a recording session and laid a bunch of stuff down. I laid down some cajón (Latin percusión standard fare), some Ladysmith Black Mambazo-esque backup vocals, and some wannabe flamenco guitar. I had no idea what words I was going to sing into the mic, but once I had all that textured music goodness backing me up, words just came out of my mouth. I came up with enough material to fill a couple of songs, actually, just singing into the mic over that loop of sweetness.
For a while after that experience, I thought I had just turned the whole process upside down, and I wondered why it had worked so well. That got me to thinking about the process itself and the mediums I used throughout:
I realized that music (the fun part!) wasn’t showing up enough in the process, and most of it was at the very end. I was doing way too much to come up with stuff in my head, and then following that up with too much pen and too much paper. I suppose that’s partly because I wanted to write songs that were well thought through. I wasn’t interested in writing the next “MmmBop”, and so I thought things through and through and through and through before actually making music.
Thinking is not the problem here, trust me. Thinking is too often what’s lacking from popular music. The problem is the medium I was using for thinking. In this case, my target medium was music – guitar, vocals, yelling, whistles, sound samples – and my primary thinking medium were brain sparks and pen and paper.
Not that brain sparks and pen and paper aren’t decent ways to think, you know, they’re great. It’s just that they’re not the most effective thinking mediums if your target medium is something else. In my case, I needed to use music as my thinking medium if I wanted to write a song, and that’s what I did by recording first. If you’re a carpenter, your best thinking medium is wood. If you’re a writer, it’s a Mac. If you’re a lawyer, it’s b.s. and the more you use your target medium as a thinking medium, the more effective your thinking becomes.
The reasons for this are several, but the most obvious is that if your thinking uses your target medium, your thoughts will have the same essential characteristics, restraints, and properties as your final product. Thus, your synthesis will be more accurate. Additionally, your evaluation will be more intuitive because it’s easier to respond to a blown glass object in blown glass form as opposed to brain spark form.
In design we have a word for thinking in non-brain-spark mediums – prototyping. We talk about it, we like it, we love it. But do we do it enough? How many activities are we undertaking with brain-spark power alone? How many more do we limit to the realm of pen and paper? How many of our thoughts actually make it to prototype form?
I think it’s only a select few. And that’s for the same reason that only a select few of my song ideas were making it to recorded format. See, I thought of recording as a way of presenting; a way to say “ah, now that I’ve done my thinking, let me show you all what I came up with” and then attempting to impress. I think too often we regard prototypes in the same way. We use them to show our client some great idea for a solution. We use them to show our team that we bring something to the table. We use them in our portfolios to say “see? I’m good at this”.
Prototyping is a great medium for presentation, and I’m not knocking it in that capacity. All I’m saying is that it’s so much more than a presentation medium. It is our most powerful thought medium.
When we face design problems, we often do so by attempting solutions (Lawson). However, far too often we attempt them only in our minds. We analyze, synthesize, and evaluate using brain sparks. We brain-spark a solution to life and then brain-spark it to death when its weaknesses occur to us. Later, we forget that we had brain-sparked that solution and return to it, only to discard it once again. How many of us have gone through that cycle time and time again in the limited realm of our minds?
Our thinking process would be far more effective if we used prototypes as a medium for thought – without reverence, without censorship, without that little voice in your head that tells you it should look better than it does because you’re going to show it to someone. We should use it as a medium to analyze the design problem, to propose solutions, to make mistakes, to fix them, and to try new things. We should make them an extension of our brains and use them as such: divergently, creatively, exploring the possibilities for a solution. We should let them replace brain sparks as a thought medium as much as possible.
By using prototypes as a thought medium we’re more likely to have a meaningful, fruitful conversation with our own ideas. We are more likely to better identify their strengths and flaws, and communicate those to others. We are more likely to think about our design problem and its solution candidates accurately. In the end, this kind of thinking is more likely to lead to an effective solution.
“It is our function as artists to make the spectator see the world our way not his way.”
Excerpt from a manifesto written by Mark Rothko, Adolph Gottlieb and Barnett Newman, published June 13, 1943, in the New York Times. Via The Footnotes of Mad Men.
“The content that sits inside of our design framework is often the final arbiter of success, yet we sometimes diminish its importance and separate ourselves from it. The more we separate our design activities from content development, the greater the risk of design failure.”
Christopher Detzi writes about The Content Conundrum, a very nice and well thought out article covering a problem every web designer must face
Of course it is totally understandable to take the ideas of those that pay our bills as gospel. But we should also be reminded that those same people hired us for our expertise. If they just wanted someone to follow orders, they’d probably have hired someone else.
This is especially true in our jobs here on North Temple Street, where design instruction can come from the same people who write actual Church doctrine. I fear too few of us stand up for our own truths, the truths of proportion and color and composition.
While our customers – and yours certainly – are well versed in the gospels of their own sphere, we are the trained experts of design. Often these people who demand that the page doesn’t scroll or whatnot haven’t a clue as to how their message should be communicated.
Instead, let us assert our expertise. Carefully take the customers’ feedback, adjust the design as you see fit, and with confidence explain why those decisions were necessary. In the end, you’ll have progressed the design in ways that improve the product – and not the egos – of your customers.
“Oh right, the flaming chainsaw animation. I’d love to
take that off the site, really I would, but I just think it’s so
neat, and besides it aligns with our brand message of innovation
here at Acme.”
VP of Marketing (presumably caricatured), quoted by Mark Hurst at Good Experience. Very funny supposed transcript of a customer meeting gone awry (or… is that really just the way things usually are?)
“Unless websites are redesigned for the special circumstances of mobile use, the mobile Web will remain a mirage.”
Jakob Nielsen in his latest Alertbox on mobile usability. No news here… which is actually part of the news.
Many findings in the most recent study—which I thought looked pretty darn thorough and well-balanced, from diary studies with users’ own phones to more controlled lab tests—suggest that in some ways we are no better off on the mobile web than we were a decade ago. (Unless you have a pretty large-screened mobile device, such as an iPhone.)
This made me think of Cameron’s advice in Mobile Web Design, that two of the best strategies are “do nothing” (if you are targetting smart phone and especially larger devices such as the iPhone that have a decent chance at rendering the site as-is) and mobile-optimized sites (if you care about anybody else).
The Human Centered Design Toolkit was created by IDEO and the Gates foundation as a free open-source toolkit to assist organizations providing services for communities in need.