design archives
“Innovation is overrated. Customers don’t care about how innovative you are. They just want to be happy and satisfied. And that’s about good design.”
Scott Berkun, discussing his new book with UIE

posted by ted on Thursday, Jul 26, 2007

How Good Design Made It Hard to Find a Place to Sleep

A while ago I noted that the opening of the first IKEA store in Utah had created significant traffic snarls for days. Well, apparently in Portland this week it was even worse.

One of our interns, Derek Caswell, reported that a new IKEA store opened in Portland this morning. He had stayed for a long weekend with family in Eugene and stayed in a Portland hotel last night prior to catching his flight back to Utah. He caught wind of the IKEA event when someone mentioned how lucky he was to get a room.

When he asked why, he was told that most hotels were fully booked—because of the IKEA opening today! People apparently traveled from all around and stayed the night in a hotel in order to get in line early on opening day.

As was the case here in Utah, the local transportation office published an IKEA Traffic Flow Plan and the airport posted a Traffic Advisory to handle the massive volume of opening day. A web search also turned up lots of other buzz around the event, including one titled, “The Swedish are Coming! The Swedish are Coming!”

When people will go to such lengths just to walk into your store for the first time, when the local transportation department and airport have to make special arrangements to handle the traffic (not for hours, but for weeks, according to the advisory), when people book all the hotels in town early just to get in the door—you are doing something awfully right.

As I said before—in my opinion, it’s not just the products, it’s the design of the whole IKEA experience, from the products, to the pricing, to the floorplan, to the food and other cultural touches, to the packaging, all the way through the instructions and assembly.

If you haven’t been, check it out. And bring your design notebook.

posted by ted on Wednesday, Jul 25, 2007

Ted, may I point you to the Ferrari of Color Scheme Generators?

posted by john on Monday, Jul 23, 2007

“Where else do you get to combine the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, Grossout Humor, and banking for tweens?”
Jess McMullin on B&A, describing the MetaMemes brainstorming game . Both the article and the game look interesting…

posted by ted on Thursday, Jul 19, 2007

Spool: Learning from the Facebook Mini-Feed Disaster

Jared Spool writes about lessons learned from the Facebook Mini-Feed Disaster, caused by the release of a new, innovative feature that kept users abreast of the activities of their Facebook friends. Instead of initially embracing the new feature, users revolted.

Interestingly, the offending feature was itself responsible for helping propagate a protest group against the feature that grew to 750,000 people.

A summary of Spool’s main points:

The full article is a good read on the importance of communicating with customers, understanding context of use, and doing your field work—especially if you are working in social contexts where people are defining their individuality.

posted by ted on Monday, Jul 16, 2007

Fun artist profile over at CGSociety of Jason Deamer, one of the character designers on Pixar’s latest flick Ratatouille. I saw the movie last night and like John thought it was excellent. Superbly written and animated, and it has much appeal to those of us over 20 (or over 30 (or over 40, Tadd)).

posted by jason on Friday, Jul 06, 2007

Edward Tufte has compiled a nice collection of Megan Jaegerman’s information news graphics. Tufte declares: “Her best work is the best work in news graphics.” Have a look.

posted by john on Thursday, Jul 05, 2007

Business card designs galore.

posted by foster on Tuesday, Jul 03, 2007

Great ad for Sony’s PSP. Via ibelieveinadv.

posted by jason on Wednesday, Jun 27, 2007

The List

Looking for inspiration? Craving instruction? Bored and need something to read? Look no further; here is the Official NorthTemple Uber List of Inspirational Instructional Books, Conferences, and other stuff. Enjoy!

Conferences/Workshops
Edward Tufte
An Event Apart

Design, Usability, and Software Development Books
The Design of Everyday Things
Author: Don Norman

The Inmates are Running the Asylum
Author: Alan Cooper

Designing with Web Standards
Author: Jeffrey Zeldman

Getting Real
Author: 37Signals

Designing for Interaction: Creating Smart Applications and Clever Devices
Author: Dan Saffer

Designing Interfaces: Patterns for Effective Interaction Design
Author: Jenifer Tidwell

Designing the Obvious: A Common Sense Approach to Web Application Design
Author: Robert Hoekman Jr.

Defensive Design for the Web
Author: 37signals, Matthew Linderman, Jason Fried

Transcending CSS: The Fine Art of Web Design
Author: Andy Clarke, Molly E. Holzschlag

Bulletproof Web Design
Author: Dan Cederholm

CSS Mastery: Advanced Web Standards Solutions
Author: Andy Budd, Simon Collison, Cameron Moll

Don’t Make Me Think: A Common Sense Approach to Web Usability
Author: Steve Krug

The Elements of User Experience: User-Centered Design for the Web
Author: Jesse James Garrett

Universal Principles of Design: 100 Ways to Enhance Usability, Influence Perception, Increase Appeal, Make Better Design Decisions, and Teach Through Design
Author: William Lidwell, Kritina Holden, Jill Butler

The Elements of Typographic Style
Author: Robert Bringhurst

Business
Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting out of the Box
Author: The Arbinger Institute

Small Is The New Big
Author: Seth Godin

Religion
The Standard Works
Conference Talks

To Draw Closer to God
Author: Henry B. Eyring

The Lord’s Way
Author: Dallin H. Oaks

Temple And Cosmos
Author: Hugh Nibley

Literature
Les Miserables
The Lord of the Rings
Ender’s Series

Blogs and Magazines
Authentic Boredom
456 Berea Street
Subtraction
A List Apart
Speak Up
Brand New
Design Observer
Boxes and Arrows
UX Magazine
UX Matters
Vitamin
Core77
Get Results Blog
Signal vs. Noise
Trizle

Reference
The Elements of Typographic Style applied to the Web
John Maeda’s Laws of Simplicity
UI Garden

Professional Organizations
Interaction Design Association
AIGA

posted by rick on Monday, Jun 25, 2007

Encountered while shoe shopping, The Mark Nason Promoter. “Gored leather with calf-hair inserts and metal studs accent these classic men’s footwear.”
Again, not that I am shopping for $400 shoes.

posted by jason on Monday, Jun 25, 2007

We can’t forget to mention the DWR airstream, for the design conscious road camper.

posted by john on Friday, Jun 22, 2007

No surprises with the Apple Design Awards at WWDC 2007.

posted by clifton on Wednesday, Jun 13, 2007

Core77 never disappoints. Today they link us to Paolo Orsacchini’s packaging for the new Italian commemorative edition of Jules Verne’s Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea. The packaging includes the book printed on waterproof paper enclosed in a pouch complete with real sea water.

posted by john on Monday, Jun 11, 2007

In 1964 Ketchum, MacLeod & Grove, Inc. (KM&G), the advertising agency that introduced Noyes to Westinghouse, produced a brochure, ‘Dear Mother’ that was inspired by Eliot’s constant struggle to improve communication. It based its concept on advice that he had given to engineers and designers at IBM. ‘Let’s pretend that everything you write is being written not to me but to your mother. Don’t say anything she wouldn’t understand, even if they seem standard in this business. And, just to keep on track, start out everything you write or dictate with the words “Dear Mother.”—quoted from Gordon Bruce’s Monograph on Eliot Noyes(p. 17)

posted by john on Thursday, Jun 07, 2007

posted by randy on Wednesday, Jun 06, 2007

Nielsen: The Myth of the Genius Designer

Jakob Nielsen has recently written to debunk the idea that all you need to do is hire a Genius Designer, and all will be well. Certainly he’s got a point. But the longer I work in an agile development environment, the more caveats I find. (OK—I, a former usability engineer, have officially drunk the Agile Design Kool-Aid.)

Nielsen starts his Alertbox article with, “I often hear the following argument against usability: Just hire a great designer, and you don’t have to worry about that pesky user testing.” He moves on to rebut that argument with some good points. I won’t re-hash all of them here, but some of his statements that need qualification.

“You must run your projects with the team you actually have, not the team you wish you had.” His point is that you may not have the luxury of working with a Design Genius; therefore the designs might have more usability problems. Sure. But “the team you actually have” might not include a dedicated usability person. Doing the best with “the team you actually have” in many cases means doing a solo act. That doesn’t necessarily mean no user research or testing, but it may very well mean another hat for designers to wear, at least some of the time. Since Nielsen has historically been a big proponent of programmers conducting their own usability tests, surely he would agree that designers could also perform this function.

“Design is an inexact science; even if you have a superb designer, not all of his or her ideas will be great.” I guess that’s true. It’s also true that not every usability engineer is created equal, nor are all studies by a given usability professional of equal validity or usefulness. But all in all I guess it’s a valid point; Good Designers can certainly produce Bad Design some of the time.

Nielsen also states that designers need empirical data on their designs to get good at design and that designers produce successful products only if their designs solve the right problems, which would require user research (my paraphrase).

Yes, testing provides some data, and for some kinds of products and development processes, it’s probably the best way to get it. But it’s far from the best data, as anybody who does field research is well aware. Real-world use is not the same as in-lab use. Under the right circumstances, the real world can provide your data instead of lots of pre-release user testing.

Before we begin development, the designers here at the Church meet with the customer, nail down requirements for a reasonably small but meaningful chunk of functionality, show them working prototypes soon thereafter, then build the real thing.

After it’s built, the customer runs through the working software and accepts it or sends it back for refinement. Because many of the products I work on are for internal release to a small number of users, a very high percentage of our user base has already seen the prototypes and given input before it is built. Furthermore, we are able to release new software about every 2 months or so to these internal customers. We start getting feedback on anything we missed pretty quickly, and have the opportunity (at our customer’s discretion) of fixing the problems and releasing the solution in another 8 weeks or less, along with our next batch of new features. You could argue that customer interviews and prototype reviews are really user research after all, but again—it can be the designer wearing that hat, not a full-time usability professional.

“Nobody’s perfect. Even a very good design can be improved when you follow an iterative process of continuous quality improvements.” I agree. But that doesn’t have to mean testing. Our process is highly iterative, meaning we iterate with prototype reviews and frequently released software, constantly delivering value out to our users where it can really be evaluated under conditions that matter.

I realize that it is not always possible to have easy access to such a large portion of your user base, nor to be able to release working software (and fixes) so frequently. Also some applications have high risk to life, limb, property, or reputation; maybe the higher that risk, the more necessary to run more extensive tests before releaseing—even if you will have the opportunity to release improvements again in a few weeks or months.

But when you have a lower risk level, frequent releases to production, and access to most of your users during development—would a robust usability program provide enough value to justify it? I do wish I had the luxury of running more tests, doing some formal contextual inquiry, and so on. But I don’t think it would be a wise use of resources in my case.

And I’m not even a Genius Designer.

posted by ted on Thursday, May 31, 2007

“One of my buddies always says never go to a meeting without a prototype, and he always wins.”
David Kelley, founder of IDEO

posted by john on Thursday, May 31, 2007

John shared this link before about “Design for the Other 90%”. Here’s a short video from the New York Times about the same thing.

posted by gilbert on Monday, May 28, 2007

How Good Design Created a Traffic Jam

Knowing my great affection for anything Scandinavian, I’m sure the whole team would be shocked and dismayed if I didn’t post something about the IKEA store opening in the Salt Lake valley. So here it is! How careful experience design created a traffic jam along I-15 and nearby surface streets.

On my way to work this morning, I looked out the bus window as I passed Bangerter Highway on I-15. I noted the new IKEA building, with a three-quarters full parking lot, balloons waving, a crowd gathering—despite the fact that the store didn’t open for another two hours. Last night on the news they announced that certain freeway offramps would be closed, and that a major surface street would be converted to one-way, all so that the high volume of expected traffic could be routed most efficiently in from the south and out through the north. People have been talking with great anticipation for weeks about the store opening.

So I ask— what’s the big deal? It’s a big box store for cryin’ out loud. No Walmart, Lowe’s, or Fill-in-the-Blank Superstore got this kind of treatment! I think there are at least two factors: Audience and Experience.

I myself am affected by the Audience factor in multiple ways. I appreciate relatively cheap, high-quality stuff, which is what IKEA makes. I further served an LDS mission in Sweden, so I appreciate the food, candy, decor, and other cultural touches you find at IKEA, especially around the holidays. I look forward to sharing many a plate of IKEA’s swedish meatballs and lingon berries with former mission companions and maybe even a convert or two who have relocated to Utah.

But you don’t have to have Swedish connections to appreciate the IKEA Experience. This is a company that doesn’t just sell you a piece of furniture. They sell you a good experience, from the minute you walk in the door, to the navigating of the floorplan, to the enjoyment of authentic Swedish cuisine, to the sheer relief of dropping the kids off in a 100% secure Playland before beginning your shopping trip, through the checkout lines, and all the way home.

Once at home you open your box and find—gasp!—highly readable instructions that are easy to follow. Less than thirty minutes later, your loft bed with student desk is assembled and your kid is telling you it’s the coolest thing she’s ever seen.

During December, be prepared to add a Santa Lucia procession complete with candle crowns and caroling in Swedish, and a glass of warm glogg in your hand. (I apologize for not finding my umlauts and other diacritics, Swedish speakers; forlat.) Add to this the scent of the pine trees lined up for sale, and you have an Atmosphere, not a store.

To sum it up, the reason people are lined up for miles to see this store open is not because they can’t wait to get that rocking chair or box of chocolates. It’s because IKEA provides a rich, memorable Experience that has been carefully designed from start to finish.

We should all be so wise in our design work.

(Also see how good experience made it hard to find a place to sleep in Portland.)

posted by ted on Wednesday, May 23, 2007