ted boren archives
In the LDS Church, each congregation is called a ward. Wards are combined into stakes (see Isaiah 54, especially verse 2). With few exceptions, both wards and stakes are geographically based, enclosing a specific area exclusive of any other ward or stake. When a ward or stake gets too large (and, less frequently, when they get too small) a re-organization of the stake is necessary, with boundary re-alignments, new wards, and so forth. In a growing area like Saratoga Springs, UT where I live, such re-organizations have become an annual event. Last night our stake was re-organized, so in honor of the occasion, a member of our stake presidency read the following list of possible hymn selections for the occasion.
These are all real hymns in the LDS hymnbook.
- Sing We Now At Parting
- I’ll Go Where You Want Me to Go
- Nay, Speak No Ill (for those dislike the counsel of the previous hymn)
- The Happy Day Has Come At Last (probably a reference to the cramped conditions that result when 700-800 people show up for meeting in a chapel designed for 600)
- Now Let Us Rejoice
What was actually on the program:
- Today While the Sun Shines (work with a will)
- Put Your Shoulder to the Wheel
posted by
ted
on Monday, Jun 11, 2007
“If the user ain’t happy, ain’t nobody happy.”
Levitation Design
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Jun 07, 2007
Free tutorial on Agile Development for New Managers to be held June 13th in Midvale (just south of Salt Lake City). Thanks to Grant Skousen and NUCHI for the pointer.
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Jun 07, 2007
Wonderful address and Q&A session with scholar Richard Bushman of Columbia examining what it might mean for the country if we had a Mormon president . Probably one of the best online discussions of Mormonism and public life that I’ve ever seen. (Sorry if this is slightly political, but I found his comments and the very civil discussion that followed so refreshing I had to share!)
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Jun 07, 2007
It’s fun every once in a while to go through the logs and see what internet searches are driving people to your site. Here are a few of the more unusual ways people are finding North Temple via Search:
posted by
ted
on Tuesday, Jun 05, 2007
“There’s no such thing as a left over cookie.”
Jim Williams, our program manager on the efficient use of lunch resources
posted by
ted
on Monday, Jun 04, 2007
“Whether people skills are effective or not depends on something deeper [than] behavior and skill… . No matter what we’re doing on the outside, people respond primarily to how we’re feeling about them on the inside.”
Corny… but true? From Leadership and Self-Deception .
posted by
ted
on Monday, Jun 04, 2007
“The men of 1960 were no longer lost in admiration of such [technological] marvels; they exploited them quite calmly, without being any happier, for, from their hurried gait, their peremptory manner, their “American” dash, it was apparent that the demon of wealth impelled them onward without mercy or relief.”
Jules Verne in a relatively newly discovered then-futuristic novel, Paris in the Twentieth Century
posted by
ted
on Friday, Jun 01, 2007
Jakob Nielsen has recently written to debunk the idea that all you need to do is hire a Genius Designer, and all will be well. Certainly he’s got a point. But the longer I work in an agile development environment, the more caveats I find. (OK—I, a former usability engineer, have officially drunk the Agile Design Kool-Aid.)
Nielsen starts his Alertbox article with, “I often hear the following argument against usability: Just hire a great designer, and you don’t have to worry about that pesky user testing.” He moves on to rebut that argument with some good points. I won’t re-hash all of them here, but some of his statements that need qualification.
“You must run your projects with the team you actually have, not the team you wish you had.” His point is that you may not have the luxury of working with a Design Genius; therefore the designs might have more usability problems. Sure. But “the team you actually have” might not include a dedicated usability person. Doing the best with “the team you actually have” in many cases means doing a solo act. That doesn’t necessarily mean no user research or testing, but it may very well mean another hat for designers to wear, at least some of the time. Since Nielsen has historically been a big proponent of programmers conducting their own usability tests, surely he would agree that designers could also perform this function.
“Design is an inexact science; even if you have a superb designer, not all of his or her ideas will be great.” I guess that’s true. It’s also true that not every usability engineer is created equal, nor are all studies by a given usability professional of equal validity or usefulness. But all in all I guess it’s a valid point; Good Designers can certainly produce Bad Design some of the time.
Nielsen also states that designers need empirical data on their designs to get good at design and that designers produce successful products only if their designs solve the right problems, which would require user research (my paraphrase).
Yes, testing provides some data, and for some kinds of products and development processes, it’s probably the best way to get it. But it’s far from the best data, as anybody who does field research is well aware. Real-world use is not the same as in-lab use. Under the right circumstances, the real world can provide your data instead of lots of pre-release user testing.
Before we begin development, the designers here at the Church meet with the customer, nail down requirements for a reasonably small but meaningful chunk of functionality, show them working prototypes soon thereafter, then build the real thing.
After it’s built, the customer runs through the working software and accepts it or sends it back for refinement. Because many of the products I work on are for internal release to a small number of users, a very high percentage of our user base has already seen the prototypes and given input before it is built. Furthermore, we are able to release new software about every 2 months or so to these internal customers. We start getting feedback on anything we missed pretty quickly, and have the opportunity (at our customer’s discretion) of fixing the problems and releasing the solution in another 8 weeks or less, along with our next batch of new features. You could argue that customer interviews and prototype reviews are really user research after all, but again—it can be the designer wearing that hat, not a full-time usability professional.
“Nobody’s perfect. Even a very good design can be improved when you follow an iterative process of continuous quality improvements.” I agree. But that doesn’t have to mean testing. Our process is highly iterative, meaning we iterate with prototype reviews and frequently released software, constantly delivering value out to our users where it can really be evaluated under conditions that matter.
I realize that it is not always possible to have easy access to such a large portion of your user base, nor to be able to release working software (and fixes) so frequently. Also some applications have high risk to life, limb, property, or reputation; maybe the higher that risk, the more necessary to run more extensive tests before releaseing—even if you will have the opportunity to release improvements again in a few weeks or months.
But when you have a lower risk level, frequent releases to production, and access to most of your users during development—would a robust usability program provide enough value to justify it? I do wish I had the luxury of running more tests, doing some formal contextual inquiry, and so on. But I don’t think it would be a wise use of resources in my case.
And I’m not even a Genius Designer.
posted by
ted
on Thursday, May 31, 2007
I had some interesting experiences last week that struck a chord with something I just read in Leadership and Self-Deception : “Whether people skills are effective or not depends on something deeper [than] behavior and skill… . No matter what we’re doing on the outside, people respond primarily to how we’re feeling about them on the inside.”
It sounds kind of corny, so I questioned this at first. But I’m coming to believe that this statement as I examine my interactions with my family and co-workers. If I’m frustrated with my kids, and that’s the main feeling in my heart, it doesn’t matter too much that I keep my voice level and say reasonable things; somehow my they sense my frustration with them and react to it defensively.
The same thing seems to hold true at work. When I am mostly thinking how I want someone else as a problem or roadblock, they seem to sense that somehow, even if I’m smiling and making chit-chat. Some defensiveness arises, finger-pointing starts, etc.
So what do you do about it? Chang
posted by
ted
on Thursday, May 31, 2007
“Identify someone with a problem and you’ll be identifying someone who resists the suggestion that he has a problem. That’s self-deception—the inability to see that one has a problem. Of all the problems in organizations, it’s the most common—and the most damaging.”
Leadership and Self-Deception
posted by
ted
on Thursday, May 31, 2007

Sundown at Larkin Cemetary, Sandy UT, on Memorial Day 2007.
Evidence of intelligent design?
Love you Grandma & Grandpa. We’ll see you later.
posted by
ted
on Monday, May 28, 2007
Nice article by Pete Whiting on managing system complexity. Lots of quotables, but my favorite: “You are more likely to be successful tailoring your system to the capabilities of your operators than tailoring the capabilities of your operators to your system.” Amen.
posted by
ted
on Sunday, May 27, 2007
Knowing my great affection for anything Scandinavian, I’m sure the whole team would be shocked and dismayed if I didn’t post something about the IKEA store opening in the Salt Lake valley. So here it is! How careful experience design created a traffic jam along I-15 and nearby surface streets.

On my way to work this morning, I looked out the bus window as I passed Bangerter Highway on I-15. I noted the new IKEA building, with a three-quarters full parking lot, balloons waving, a crowd gathering—despite the fact that the store didn’t open for another two hours. Last night on the news they announced that certain freeway offramps would be closed, and that a major surface street would be converted to one-way, all so that the high volume of expected traffic could be routed most efficiently in from the south and out through the north. People have been talking with great anticipation for weeks about the store opening.

So I ask— what’s the big deal? It’s a big box store for cryin’ out loud. No Walmart, Lowe’s, or Fill-in-the-Blank Superstore got this kind of treatment! I think there are at least two factors: Audience and Experience.
I myself am affected by the Audience factor in multiple ways. I appreciate relatively cheap, high-quality stuff, which is what IKEA makes. I further served an LDS mission in Sweden, so I appreciate the food, candy, decor, and other cultural touches you find at IKEA, especially around the holidays. I look forward to sharing many a plate of IKEA’s swedish meatballs and lingon berries with former mission companions and maybe even a convert or two who have relocated to Utah.
But you don’t have to have Swedish connections to appreciate the IKEA Experience. This is a company that doesn’t just sell you a piece of furniture. They sell you a good experience, from the minute you walk in the door, to the navigating of the floorplan, to the enjoyment of authentic Swedish cuisine, to the sheer relief of dropping the kids off in a 100% secure Playland before beginning your shopping trip, through the checkout lines, and all the way home.
Once at home you open your box and find—gasp!—highly readable instructions that are easy to follow. Less than thirty minutes later, your loft bed with student desk is assembled and your kid is telling you it’s the coolest thing she’s ever seen.
During December, be prepared to add a Santa Lucia procession complete with candle crowns and caroling in Swedish, and a glass of warm glogg in your hand. (I apologize for not finding my umlauts and other diacritics, Swedish speakers; forlat.) Add to this the scent of the pine trees lined up for sale, and you have an Atmosphere, not a store.
To sum it up, the reason people are lined up for miles to see this store open is not because they can’t wait to get that rocking chair or box of chocolates. It’s because IKEA provides a rich, memorable Experience that has been carefully designed from start to finish.
We should all be so wise in our design work.
(Also see how good experience made it hard to find a place to sleep in Portland.)
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, May 23, 2007
“The best way to increase your monitor resolution? Clean your glasses. I’m serious.”
Jacob, our Java intern, as he wiped his spectacles this morning
posted by
ted
on Monday, May 21, 2007
“If you can’t flee or fly… flow.”
Sister Matthews, one of the many wonderful volunteers I get to work with, as cited on Dave Musser’s whiteboard
posted by
ted
on Thursday, May 17, 2007
“You’ve got to nail the human-to-human interaction before you even think about human-computer interaction.”
Jason Lynes discussing the importance of communication with our new intern (and we’re still hiring, by the way)
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, May 16, 2007
A fun series of nags for CSSEdit registration, summarized on Geek & Mild. My favorite: “A disruption in the Force I feel. Not registered you have. Make a choice you must. Use or not use, for try leads to the Dark Side.” There’s a good chance you might find yourself actually reading these instead of dismissing them or getting annoyed!
posted by
ted
on Monday, May 14, 2007

Yeah, but is that the best Adobe (?!) can do?
Creating substitute icons might be nerdy ... but lookin’ at the official ones, I feel a yawn comin’ on…
posted by
ted
on Friday, May 11, 2007