ted boren archives
Jared Spool writes in a recent article, “Designing an account registration and sign-in process that doesn’t frustrate users turns out to be very difficult to achieve. It looks easy at the outset, but a pile of subtleties can sneak up on your experience, making something that should be simple become stressful for the users.” He’s right; something that should be so easy is so easy to get wrong. Here’s a summary of Spool’s “8 Design Mistakes to Avoid” for account sign-in, along with a few of my own observations:
- Mistake #1: Having a Sign-in In The First Place. I couldn’t agree more. I see so many sites that require a sign-in without providing any apparent value to the site, and (worse) no value to the user—a recipe for a zero return rate.
- Mistake #2: Requiring Sign-in Too Soon and Mistake #3: Not Stating the Benefits to Registering. People need to be motivated first. You have to show them at least some of the goods before they will entrust you with their time and information.
- Mistake #4: Hiding the Sign-In Button and Mistake #6: Not Providing Sign-in Opportunities at Key Locations. (No comment.)
- Mistake #5: Not Making “Create New Account” or “Forgot Your Password” a Button or Link. Between my wife and me, we probably forget at least one ID or password per week. How ‘bout you?
- Mistake #7: Asking for Too Much Information When Registering. Usually the designer wants a clean, straightforward experience, but someone on the business or marketing side wants to turn a legitimate registration need into a 10-page segmentation survey! Designers—push back! Convince the business side that you should ask the bare minimum, or wave goodbye to most of your registrants.
- Mistake #8: Not Telling Users How You’ll Use Their Information.
For more discussion and examples, see the full article . Also see Aaron Cannon’s post on the impact captchas could have on disabled users as part of a sign-in process.
Also see Spool’s follow-up article with 8 more sign-in design mistakes.
posted by
ted
on Friday, Jan 04, 2008
“It was a divine intervention, not a design intervention this time.”
Design Team member on Extreme Home Makeover tonight (my favorite design-related TV show, followed closely by Ace of Cakes), commenting on a touching moment when a bone marrow donor meets the little girl who received it…
posted by
ted
on Saturday, Dec 29, 2007
My parents are currently serving a mission for the LDS Church at the New Zealand Temple in Hamilton. They are in charge of an annual Temple Lights celebration that draws thousands of people to the temple grounds each season. In many ways it is similar to the displays on Temple Square in Salt Lake City, except it’s 70 degrees outside and the lights are wrapped around palm trees!
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Dec 27, 2007

What to do with Grandma’s Christmas check…
My wife pulled me and the older kids aside tonight and told us she knew what she wanted to do with some of the money we had received from relatives for Christmas this year. We sat down and watched part of a PBS Frontline program about Kiva, an online service that makes it possible for anyone to become a microlender. For $25 you can help change somebody’s life—and thanks to the internet, that somebody has a face, has a story, and has a way to let you know what they need, how things are going, and what your money has helped accomplish. The most impressive detail from the documentary: 100% re-payment rate. Wow. Absolutely awesome idea—maybe one of those things that God actually intended the Internet to be used for!
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, Dec 26, 2007

A White Christmas in Utah County.
An already white Christmas Eve got three or four inches whiter last night. (Mount Timpanogos.)
posted by
ted
on Tuesday, Dec 25, 2007

Cranes and Friends, Farmington Bay, Great Salt Lake.
This year’s beautiful addition to my uncle Ray’s incredible collection of home-made Christmas cards. Every year we get a lovingly hand-crafted, personally designed card with photos collected throughout the year. (More of Ray’s work can be found at Scenicutah.com. )
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 24, 2007
Temple Square at Christmas is best known for its lights, but you should also check out the many nativity displays depicting the Savior’s birth. I especially liked the design of the international versions of the nativity this year, emphasizing the universality of Christ’s mission and importance. If you haven’t been yet, take the opportunity! Great for the kids too.
posted by
ted
on Saturday, Dec 22, 2007
“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.”
Mark Twain, via a co-worker’s email sig
posted by
ted
on Friday, Dec 21, 2007
“Boys, you may NOT jump your bikes over Nigel no matter HOW many feet of clearance you have!”
A friend, quoting herself in her yearly Christmas newsletter… Made me think whether the guy in Aaron’s photo got started jumping over his uncle, before working up to angels…
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Dec 20, 2007
“I look at that thing and I get a visual dial-tone on my face…”
A customer, describing his reaction to a confusing (third-party) application
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, Dec 19, 2007
“By Rob Thomas’s standards, my hair is long.”
Gilbert Lee, speaking about the dress code. (See the Crew to get the joke…)
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, Dec 19, 2007
Terry Coatta makes a good case for why self-documenting code is often insufficient to a complete understanding of the code.
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 10, 2007
If a minivan is a sure sign of impending doom (per Jeremy Clarkson), then I must be on death’s door in my 12 passenger full-size van. But there are unexpected design benefits to a really big vehicle…
We graduated to the van upon the birth of our seventh child (yes, seventh), and our Ford Expedition no longer had enough seats. (We now lovingly refer to it as “the little car.”) So we went shopping for something with 9 seats.
Unfortunately, you can’t easily find a car with 9 seats. You can get 8, 12, or 15 without much effort, but finding a 9-seater is… Well, it’s like George Banks in Father of the Bride—frustrated that his hotdogs come in packs of 8 while the bun company only sells packs of 12, he is convinced that there’s a conspiracy to force him to buy 4 more buns he doesn’t need! Clearly, the auto industry, in a conspiracy against large families, has made the next step up from 8 seats a gargantuan leap of 50% to 12 seats. (And the first dealer we went to actually tried to talk us into a 15 seater because they didn’t have a 12 seater on the lot! I honestly don’t think it would have fit into my garage…)
So now I have 3 empty seats. But you know what? It’s one of those “bugs” that ends up being a design feature. Three seats means there is space between children. Always a good thing. Three empty seats means enough room to put your books or games next to you on a long road trip. Three empty seats means less feet getting stomped as the clan clambers into position. All in all, three empty seats has been a good thing.
The surprising thing—the full-size van gets very close to the same gas mileage as “the little car”. Go figure!
In closing, hail to the intrepid parents who refuse to be daunted by the car industry’s flagrant attempts to limit family size to 8 or less! Hail to empty seats! Hail to the people movers!
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 10, 2007
“Man in wheelchair: You can take that seat.
Man standing up: That’s OK—I’m sitting down all day.
Man in wheelchair (with a broad grin): Me too!”
Overheard on the train this morning. If everybody with challenges (physical or otherwise) accepted them with such grace and good humor, and everybody with fewer challenges were so considerate, what a difference it would make!
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Dec 06, 2007
Yesterday we had the privilege of listening to Bishop McMullin, at our department’s Christmas devotional. I guess that’s one more thing that is different (and cool) about working here.
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, Dec 05, 2007
“Never tell anyone we don’t have enough resources to do a project. It makes us look lame. Instead, say we have a fixed capacity that is already dedicated to higher priorities. That makes whoever asked us for help look lame.”
The Pointy Haired Boss, instructing Dilbert and associates. This approach NOT recommended… (Thanks for the link, Sharky!)
posted by
ted
on Tuesday, Dec 04, 2007

Alan Taylor’s beautiful poster of the major bodies in our solar system.
John comments, “There floats Earth—alone—the only ‘living’ rock among numbers of lifeless orbs. It looks out of place, almost freakish, but even more beautiful for being so.”
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 03, 2007
“Listen Daddy! I can be a chipskunk!”
My three year old, imitating Alvin, Simon, and Theodore singing the classic “Christmas Song”
posted by
ted
on Sunday, Dec 02, 2007
“The new password is “YoureGrounded4Life”.”
My wife, upon learning from my daughter that she had cracked our laptop’s password.
posted by
ted
on Saturday, Dec 01, 2007