john dilworth archives

I like your clarification Ted. I’ve been thinking about this idea of the Generalist and the “Rennaissance Man”, maybe it will come together in a future article…

To add just a few interesting points;

Even Leonardo was better at some things than he was at others (I don’t think any of his designs for flying machines even came close to working). He began his training as a painter under Veraccio and built his “Renaissance Man” status over the course of his whole life.

Michaelangelo also started his career as a specialist. As a sculptor, he created the “David” at the age of 24. However, it is his last work that exhibits his true achievement in multiple disciplines. His design of the dome for St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome was completed just before his death at the age of 70. This last achievement combines his “generalist” knowledge of architecture, sculpture, painting and engineering.

posted by john on Thursday, Nov 20, 2008

Does anyone ever want to be known as a compartmentalist?

I agree with you on this point, economics are not the only reason to hire a specialist. I think that the time to hire a specialists, is when you can clearly define the problem you need them to tackle. If you are hiring them for a full time position, you’d best be sure that you have enough of their specialty work to keep them busy.

I like to believe that you are always better off if you can hire a generalist. A generalist isn’t a specialist at everything, but that doesn’t mean that they can’t be very good (maybe even specialists) at several things.

posted by john on Monday, Nov 17, 2008

Sometimes, when design rhetoric and deep discussions (such as the one presented by Frank this week) start to cramp my brain, I like to unwind by reading science fiction. One of my favorite authors is Dr. Ronald Chevalier. His work is deep. The graphic design of his site is a bit dated, and a bit over-the-top, but I highly recommend it.

A Cluster Award-winning, published author since the age of 13, Dr.Chevalier’s robust body of work includes titles such as Cyborg Harpies, Brain Cream, and the all new, completely original novel Brutus & Balzaak. Currently, Dr. Chevalier lives on a ranch in southern Utah.

posted by john on Friday, Oct 31, 2008

“Embracing the word “ugly”—so readily identified with everything popular design claims to have been a reaction against—seems a logical choice if we are to create a vision for the practice of design freed from the restrictions and prejudices of its past.”
Tad Toulis makes an argument for Ugly, suggesting that our pre-conceived ideas about beauty and aesthetics may be a dogma that is actually holding us back. Great read from Core 77.

posted by john on Thursday, Oct 30, 2008

“In the Shaker world, the appearance of a thing or person mattered only to the extent that it revealed its underlying function. Whatever did not interfere with function, served function. This is different from saying that whatever did not serve function interfered with function.”
A few weeks ago, Kaleb posted a bit about the Shaker Design Philosophy. This post inspired me to look back through the book Shaker Built where I found this subtle shift in thinking. Thinking this way about your designs allows you to create something simple without being plain. It also allows the artist or designer an incredible amount of freedom within what may otherwise be considered hefty constraints. As long as a design element doesn’t interfere with the essential function, there can be an argument to keep it, even if it doesn’t serve any purpose itself.

posted by john on Tuesday, Oct 28, 2008

Typeface.js is a javascript solution for embedding fonts. The supported browsers include Firefox 1.5+, Safari 2+, and Internet Explorer 6+.

I haven’t tested this out, but it looks like it may be an alternative to Flash based solutions for custom fonts.

posted by john on Monday, Oct 27, 2008

I’ve been waiting for consumer electronics to start using materials other than plastic and metal in the industrial design. Check out this new Skype phone made out of American walnut from Hulger (via Core 77 ).

posted by john on Saturday, Sep 13, 2008

Thanks to Aaron The NorthTemple Twitterfeed is up and running. Be notified of new posts on NorthTemple through your twitter account.

If you are already suffering from Twitter addiction, we know you can’t resist. If you are not yet addicted, we can only offer a serious warning (more on Twitter’s addictive nature to follow).

posted by john on Thursday, Sep 04, 2008

northtemple journal of design  ~  September Issue

The Road to Design Expertise

Chinese philosophers and graphic designers in equal tow, John pulls off at a rest stop to lift a signpost on the road to becoming a design expert.

posted by john on Tuesday, Sep 02, 2008

“In typography neither the old style nor the new style matters; quality does.”
Jan Tschichold, On Typography (1957) — Jason Santa Maria provides a nice little piece about Tschichold’s change of heart, from his youthful days of san-serif only typographic rebellion in Nazi Germany to his latter years of classical inspiration as the head designer for Penguin Press. Tschichold’s writing and design work is something that every designer should be familiar with.

posted by john on Tuesday, Aug 26, 2008

“1 million design students will graduate this year in China, the United States will graduate 40 thousand.”

On September 9th, Christopher Liechty from the AIGA XCD (Center for Cross Cultural Design) will be presenting findings from a recent field trip to China. The presentation will take place at the Art institute in Draper (121 W. Election Road) at 7:00 pm ($5 for AIGA members, $10 for non-members).

This sounds like a great opportunity to get a look at the state of design in China, especially after seeing all the great design and work from the Beijing Olympics.

Additional request: Can someone please fix the SLC AIGA web site? I’d love to link to some official information, but can’t find anything about this particular event online.

posted by john on Monday, Aug 25, 2008

On the LDS tech web site, Michelle writes a nice follow-up to a recent in-house design workshop: Solving Design Problems at the Church.

posted by john on Monday, Aug 25, 2008

case study

Biweekly Design Review Recap

As a team, we hold regular design reviews to improve our work and the quality of our projects. A formal design review with our complete staff is held every other week, where selected presenters showcase their projects and are able to solicit feedback from other designers who are not members of their immediate project team.

The reviews are a great educational opportunity, a chance to make your work better. They also provide rare opportunities to see what everyone else on the team is working on, as well as providing a forum for us to discuss larger initiatives such as visual consistency, our design process and accessibility.

Although we can’t share publicly all the work that we review, I’m planning to provide a weekly update of our design reviews, highlighting some projects, as well as some principles that are discussed in them.

This week’s recap

Receiving Feedback: This week’s design review included a short discussion about how to take feedback. Anyone who puts themselves up regularly for critique knows that it is not easy to have people tell you what is wrong with your work. If we get defensive about our work and have a rebuttal or opinion for every single comment, we may effectively be telling them that we don’t want their feedback. There is a time to defend your design, but not in the forum where you are asking people for their opinion.

Roadmap: Todd Eriksen presented a small project that he’s developed to help facilitate some of the work related to project management. The projects that we work on are often complicated, including hundreds of prototype pages, thousands business rules, and detailed processes that are all surfaced in a visual user interface. Our role as interaction designers often requires us not only to design the screen, but to organize, keep track of and communicate the work we’ve done to other teams. This part of the effort can take as much (if not more) work than the design itself. Todd showed us some things that he’s created to help make that part of the work less laborious.

NorthTemple: Jason Lynes led a discussion around NorthTemple.com, and the direction we hope to take the site as a team. The design review provided an opportunity to get input from the other contributors on how we can make northtemple.com a better resource. We’ve received both good and bad feedback from the design community. Some things that were discussed included respecting copyright laws, the need to stay positive, to stay on topic (design related), avoid “inside jokes”, explain ourselves better, and to contribute original thoughts and ideas rather than just re-linking from other blogs.

posted by john on Thursday, Aug 14, 2008

Cameron will be presenting for the local Salt Lake City AIGA chapter tonight at the Art Institute of Salt Lake. His topic will include some discussion and thoughts on some of the things we’ve done as a team here to promote design excellence.

posted by john on Thursday, Aug 14, 2008

This innovative shadow signage on a Hotel in Florence is a great example of originality and an intelligent use of materials. The letters are formed by the shadows created by the overhead spotlight. The effect makes its own statement in a simple, beautiful way. (via core77).

posted by john on Tuesday, Jul 22, 2008

Book Review: How Designer’s Think: The Design Process Demystified by Brian Lawson (4th Edition).

A month ago, in preparation for an in-house design workshop, we handed out 30 copies of Brian Lawson’s Book “How Designers Think:The Design Process Demystified” to our designers. I first came across the first edition of this book nearly 10 years ago when I started a job at a small design firm in Salt Lake City. I had just moved from a large fairly structured company into a small, very organic company with very little structure at all. I found a first edition book on the company bookshelf and started reading.

I’ll have to admit that the first read was very difficult. The book is quite academic – the author approaches the subject from the perspective an architect who also happens to have doctorate in psychology. Most of the examples in the book discuss architecture and it can take some extra mental work to draw parallels to the profession of graphic and interaction design. In many ways, I found Lawson’s book to be very refreshing.

Lawson’s unique background allow him to approach design from a unique “scientific” perspective, while his design background from architecture, a design discipline provides a balanced perspective. It doesn’t go to far into esoteric design theory that is often discussed by practicing designers, and it doesn’t try to be to prescriptive, a fault which often appears when scientists and engineers write about design. He is able to talk in the language of design, where other authors like Don Norman and Jacob Nielson seem to speak about design in the language of science. There’s actually a great chapter in the book where Lawson illustrates the difference between the scientific approach, and the “designerly” approach. It’s especially comforting to hear it from someone who has practiced both disciplines.

I think that this unique perspective makes the book especially interesting and useful to any practicing designer. Lawson covers the essence of design, the definition of problems, and artfully describes different approaches to the design process. His model of the design process is the best I’ve ever found (chapter 3). He describes design as a “negotiation between problem and solution through the activities of analysis, synthesis and evaluation.” Other essentials deal with strategies for measuring the success and value of design (Chapter 5), and chapter 7 provides an excellent overview of the nature of design solutions, problems, and processes (chapter 7).

My favorite chapter, and the one that has influenced my work perhaps the most, is chapter 13: Design Traps. Lawson outlines several common traps that designers find themselves in. You can’t read this chapter and not have an “aha” moment, or cringe at the things which might be affecting your design right now.

I consider this book a “must read” and believe that it is one of the best books on the subject. The viewpoint is unique, and it provides beneficial knowledge that will help you in all aspects of the design profession.

We’re looking forward to the discussion next Friday.

posted by john on Thursday, Jul 10, 2008

“Once your user base has grown beyond a certain point, you cannot take features away from them. They will freak out. Whether the feature is good or bad, once you launch it you’ve married it.”
Ryan at 37Signals

posted by john on Sunday, Jul 06, 2008

“For the most part, the creation or effects of design, unlike science, are neither measurable nor predictable, nor are the results necessarily repeatable. If there is any assurance, besides faith, a businessman can have, it is in choosing talented, competent, and experienced designers.”
Paul Rand, A Designer’s Art

posted by john on Wednesday, Jun 25, 2008

Rob Thomas (our design manager) and Pete Lasko are both competing today in the Ironman. The Ironman triathalon includes a 2.4 mile swim, a 112 mile bike ride, and then just for fun, they run a full 26.2 mile marathon after that. We wish them the best of luck.

posted by john on Sunday, Jun 22, 2008

What is going on here? I thought that the UI in FireFox 3 was broken, but I guess this is what they wanted it to look like. However bad it looks, it is a great example of misplaced dissonance.

posted by john on Thursday, Jun 19, 2008